image/svg+xml19 VI/1/2015 INTERDISCIPLINARIA ARCHAEOLOGICA NATURAL SCIENCES IN ARCHAEOLOGY homepage: http://www.iansa.eu Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires Inke Achterberg a* , Andreas Bauerochse b , Thomas Giesecke a , Alf Metzler b , Hanns Hubert Leuschner a a Department for Palynology and Climate Dynamics, University of Goettingen, Untere Karspuele 2, 37073 Göttingen, Germany b Lower Saxony State Service of Cultural Heritage, Scharnhorststr. 1, 30175 Hanover, Germany 1. Introduction The northwest-German lowland changed in the millennia following the last glacial: from a periglacial wasteland to a forest-wetland mosaic, a landscape where the expanding mires eventually covered about one third of the area (Behre 2008; Metzler 2006). While the North Sea successively claimed the land between Denmark and England, pushing ground water levels up and maritime conditions further south-east, people bridged the spreading mires by wooden trackways, evidently since the early Neolithic (Metzler 2006). Finds of peat-preserved trackways are frequently reported for northwest Germany ( e.g. Metzler 2006), and also from Ireland (Raftery 1996) and southwest England (Coles and Coles 1992). Whether their construction (Behre 2005; Metzler 2003), or possibly their preservation (Spurk et al. 2002), might be related to environmental changes and climatic fuctuations is debated (Bauerochse 2003; Baillie and Brown 1996). In Ireland, the occurrence of fve “lulls” in trackway construction activity between the Neolithic and Modern Age was found to relate rather to cultural changes than to long-term hydrological variations (Plunkett et al. 2013). The present study, however, is focused rather on the precise alignment of individual constructions with the mostly short (decadal) phases of water table rise in northwest Germany. Indications for increased humidity in trackway layers have been repeatedly described – using pollen and peat analysis ( e.g. Bauerochse 2003; Leuschner et al. 2007). Whether the constructions were actually contemporaneous to or following such environmental change is investigated in this study using dendrochronology. This provides precise dating for both the trackway constructions and the mire water table rise. The latter is possible due to the large dendrochronological record of peat-preserved trees, originating from former mire (and mire-margin) woodland Volume VI ● Issue 1/2015 ● Pages 19–29 *Corresponding author. E-mail: iachter@gwdg.de ARTICLE INFO Article history: Received: 8 th August 2014Accepted: 19 th July 2015 Keywords: wooden trackwaysdendrochronologymireenvironmental changeHolocene climateNeolithic ABSTRACT Tree rings provide not only a precise dating tool, but also contain information on environmental change. The well replicated tree ring record of northwest Germany therefore provides environmental implications with immanent, absolute and precise dating from 6703 BC to 931 AD. This offers the opportunity to investigate the environmental context of archaeological fnds, if they, too, are dated by dendrochronology. We investigated 13 peat-preserved trackways from the Northwest-German lowland between 4629 BC (Neolithic) and 502 AD (Migration Period) for contemporaneousness with water table rise in the landscape. Such environmental change is well refected in the clearly notable die-off phases of trees preserved in the mires. As an environmental proxy, the parameter “ tree die-off rate a-30 ” is introduced: The annual number of tree die-off events is divided by the number of live trees 30 years previously. Overall, the majority of trackway constructions were found to be contemporane-ous to mire water table rise and mire expansion. Possibly, a period of water table rise was a motivation for trackway construction.
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 20 in the study area. The tree-ring record consists of 4700 trees, oak ( Quercus spec . ) and pine ( Pinus sylvestris ), from the mires of the northwest-German lowland. The chronologies span from 6703 BC to 931 AD (at various stages described by, for example, Delorme 1983; Leuschner et al. 2002; Eckstein et al. 2011). The peat-preserved trees grew at sites strongly affected by hydrological change ( e.g. Schweingruber 1993; Linderholm 2002; Eckstein 2010). The trees show phases of woodland establishment, growth and collapse (Eckstein et al. 2011). These phases show much synchrony across different sites in the study area (Eckstein et al. 2011), and also with the Netherlands, Ireland (Leuschner 2002) and Southern Sweden (Edvardsson 2011). They therefore qualify as an indicator for environmental change in the region, which ought to be mostly climatically driven (Leuschner 2002). The phases of high tree mortality (die-off phases) have been identifed to indicate mire expansion and mire water table rise. This was evident on the basis of upward growing roots, the composition of peat forming plants and the degree of decomposition (Leuschner et al. 2002; 2007; Eckstein et al. 2009; 2010). Tree die-off phases are a good indicator for mire water table rise (Leuschner et al. 2002; 2007; Eckstein 2009; 2010), whereas tree-ring-width (TRW) has been found to refect hydrological changes not exclusively at central European mire sites (Dauskane et al. 2011). The meteorological implication of mire water table rise and mire expansion varies, but here, we focus on the timing of such landscape-level changes rather than their causes.This study investigates a possible correlation of trackway construction with mire water table rise and mire expansion. In the following, dendrochronological dates for wooden trackways are evaluated for contemporaneity to die-off phases of the peat-preserved trees from the area. 2. Material and methods2.1 The peat-preserved trees of northwest Germany The tree species regarded in this study only include oak ( Quercus spec.) and pine ( Pinus sylvestris ). The woodland remains were preserved in peat, and mostly exposed by peat-harvesting. A total of 2090 oak and 2610 pine trees from northwest-German mires, spanning from 6703 BC to 931 AD, form the environmental record. These remains are only tree stumps and stems; no timbers from human constructions, like the trackways or buildings, are included in the environmental record.The chronology of peat-preserved oaks cross-dates well with the Göttingen chronology of timbers from buildings and other constructions, which reaches back from the present (2009 AD) to 610 BC. The main sections of both (oak and pine) chronologies of peat-preserved tree remains cross-date well with the Göttingen chronology of riverine oak from central and northwest Germany, which covers from 7197 BC to 1136 AD. All sections of the peat-preserved pine chronology are securely cross-dated with the peat-preserved oak chronology. Figure 1. Study area in northwest Germany. Elevations are shaded and sampling sites indicated. 0 100 km
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 21 Generally, tree die-off refects (a period of) water table rise in the mires and mire expansion. These are related to hydrological changes, depending on sites. Ground-water levels relate to effective precipitation, and – at least in coastal areas – can be affected by sea level changes (Behre 2008). Trees from fen sites (minerogenic mires) are affected by ground water table fuctuations (Leuschner et al. 1986). In contrast, trees on raised bog sites (rain-fed mires) should mark dry phases (Moir 2010). Many of the trees were preserved at the base of raised bog peat, and therefore mark phases of raised bog expansion. Raised bogs function like sponges collecting rain water. Raised bog communities are highly competitive under nutrient-poor conditions in moist climates (Van Breemen 1995). Even though raised bog development is largely associated with high effective precipitation (Overbeck 1975), raised bog development atop fen peat can also be favoured by decreasing ground water tables (von Bülow 1935; Hughes 2004; Tahvanainen 2011). High precipitation results in accelerated peat-accumulation, which eventually disconnects the mire surface from the ground water (Overbeck 1975). Intermediate dry phases can also favour raised bog development on fen peat, by lowering the ground water table and thereby cutting the nutrient-supply to the surface (von Bülow 1935; Hughes 2004; Tahvanainen 2011). The fen-bog transition is often marked by tree layers, their die-off phases indicating the beginning of raised bog growth.The two tree species are represented unevenly at different sites. Generally, the more competitive oak dominates the nutrient-richer sites infuenced by ground water. The oak material from such low-elevation sites displays long and dispersed die-off phases, caused by ground water level rise along an elevation gradient (Leuschner 2003). Fen sites at the transition to raised bog are rather levelled in elevation and water table. Hydrological changes at these sites cause distinct die-off phases in both species. The undemanding pine dominates only at poor sites. The occurrence of subfossil pines often marks the fen-bog-transition. The record also contains pines from sandy sites at the base of the peat and from raised-bog layers. The latter occur only occasionally and are most indicative of climatic variation (Moir 2010). Pine die-off phases are typically rather distinct, due to the more levelled character of the sites and to the sensitivity of trees growing close to their ecological limit.Differences in wood preservation between the two species add to their disparity. The pines are mostly preserved to bark edge, which enhances the more distinct appearance of the pine die-off phases. In contrast, many of the oaks are preserved to the heartwood-sapwood boundary. Estimated numbers of missing rings were added for the die-off dates, but this naturally is less precise by comparison.Tree die-off is a good indicator for the occurrence of mire water level rise in the study area. However, restrictions should be considered: frstly, drowning trees can take a few years to die, and therefore the die-off phase will be slightly lagging behind the beginning of water table rise. Secondly, the absence and the end of die-off phases are somewhat less reliable indicators. This is due to the detection of water level rise by this method requiring suffciently old trees at affected sites, which can at times be absent or already dead. 2.2 The trackways Over 300 peat-preserved trackways have been reported for the region (Metzler 2006), but precise ( i.e. dendrochronological) dates for them are scarce. The dendrochronological trackway-dates from the study area include dates taken from literature, as well as age determinations performed in the dendrochronological laboratories of Göttingen (indicated in Table 1). The number of dendrochronological dates for Table 1. The dendrochronologically-dated trackways of the northwest-German lowland. Dates refer to the last measured ring. Construction date no.Construction dateTrackway IDTimber datesBog AreaPublished i.a. 14629– 4545 BC Pr31 4628–4545 BC 1 CampemoorBauerochse et al. 201223798 BC Pr35 3798 BC 1 CampemoorBauerochse et al. 201233701 BC Pr34 3701 BC 1 CampemoorBauerochse et al. 201242900–2882 BC Pr32 2900–2882 BC 1 CampemoorLeuschner et al. 200751357 BC Wanna 1357 BC 1 b. Wannaunpublished Ip36 / Pr36 1357 BC 2 IpwegermoorSchmidt 19926754–749 BC Ip12a 754–749 BC 2 IpwegermoorSchmidt 19927719–713 BC–682 BC Le21Le9 719–718 BC 2 , 683/682 BC 2 Lengener MoorSchmidt 1992717–714 BC 2 Lengener MoorSchmidt 1992 Ip12Ip62 716–713 BC 1,2 b. OldenburgSchmidt 1992b. Oldenburg8128 BC Ip42 128 BC1WittemoorMetzler 2006960–43 BC Pr6 60–55 BC, 43 BC53–46 BC 1,2 Großes Moor b. DiepholzFansa, Schneider 199610222 AD Pr4 222 AD 1,2 Großes Moor b. DiepholzFansa, Schneider 199611497–502 AD Uchte 497–502 AD 1 Uchter Moorunpublished 1 – dated by B. Leuschner, DELAG; 2 – dated by B. Schmidt.
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 22 peat-preserved wooden trackways is relatively low, due to the early excavation of the trackways since the 19 th century, when dendrochronological dating was not suffciently established and the long tree-ring-chronologies had not yet been developed. The trackways that are included vary greatly in number of dated timbers, preservation state of the wood and documentation. Therefore, detailed evaluations ( i.e. the time-span of usage, etc. ) were not possible in most cases. Trackways without certain and precise determination of at least one felling date were excluded. Figure 2. [A] gives the lifespans of trees, sorted by time of death and mire area of origin (several sites taken together). Severe die-off events are indicated by vertical lines (grey). [B] gives the annual tree die-off (black flled, scale on the left), and the corresponding die-off rate a-30 (black line, scale on the right). Both are smoothed by a 15-year running mean. The mean value of the die-off rate a-30 is indicated by a horizontal line.
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 23 The study includes 12 (+1) trackways (Table 1). The northwest-German trackway fnds have archaeological IDs (indicating the location or frst investigator). Two of the trackways included in this study have no IDs to our knowledge, and are designated by their place of origin ( i.e. Wanna and Uchte ). In some cases, two trackways excavated at different times, turned out later to be parts of one trackway, interrupted by mineral soil islands in the mire. Their sections have been united for this study, using both original trackway-IDs ( i.e. Ip12&Ip62 and Le9&Le21 ). Conversely, one trackway appeared under dendrochronological investigation to contain timbers from a predecessor construction (Schmidt 1992). This construction previous to Ip12 is called Ip12a in the following.Also, simultaneous constructions occur. This study has a temporal focus, and therefore 11 construction dates are referred to, rather than 12 (+1) trackways (Table 1). 2.2.1 Excluded trackways Five dendrochronologically-dated trackways were excluded, because erosion and decay on the outer parts of timbers did not allow for precise determination of felling dates. The “dates after which” for these trackways are: Bc34, after 763BC and after 752 BC; Pr3, after c. 665–640 BC; Pr25, after 218–160 BC; Bc32, after 85 AD and after 120 AD; Cl01, after 273 AD and after 334 AD. 2.3. Method: die-off rate a-30 As described in section 1, the peat-preserved trees from the area display synchronous phases of tree-establishment and common die-off. The die-off phases in particular are highly indicative of hydrological change (water table rise and mire expansion). However, the heterogeneous replication and overlapping woodland phases in the record do not allow for a good determination of die-off phases via die-off frequency, replication or die-off percentage.Therefore, a measure called die-off rate a-30 was developed, i.e. annual tree die-off divided by replication 30 years previously. The time lag of 30 years was chosen according to the common length of tree generations and die-off phases in the data-set. This reduced the replication-dependency of die-off peak- height, while retaining the temporal distribution of the die-off phases (Figure 2).Oak and pine have been combined in the die-off rate a-30 displayed in Figure 2, and are displayed separately in Figure 3. A separation by species is advantageous, as the environmental signal of both species is not entirely identical – due to ecological differences.The estimated number of rings missing to bark was closely examined for the die-off dates. A reduced data-set was tested in which all samples with a standard deviation of missing rings to bark larger than 3 (eroded samples) were excluded. This produced no notable alteration of the curve. Figure 3. The die-off rate a-30 is displayed for oaks (black), pines (red), smoothed by a 15-year running mean. The tree die-off rate a-30 (average of the other two curves) is shown (grey, flled) with its mean value (grey horizontal line). The trackway timber dates are indicated by vertical lines (blue), with coloured boxes uniting dates from one fnd. The construction date numbers are given above, in grey for construction dates outside of die-off phases. The trackway-IDs are given below the date numbers.
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 24 As mentioned above, the vast majority of pines are preserved to bark edge. The oaks mostly feature sapwood, which allows for good estimations, and in several cases sapwood rings could not be measured, but it was still possible to count them.To show the relation between die-off frequency and the die-off rate a-30 , dates of all trees are shown and used to calculate the die-off rate a-30 in Figure 2. But because pine is clustered in the record in large numbers, their signal swallows up that of oak, which had not been sampled in the same fashion. To retain the environmental signal as best as possible, the tree-die-off rate a-30 used in the following was calculated differently: die-off rate a-30 was calculated for each species, and smoothed by a 15-year running mean (Figure 3). These oak and pine values were averaged to gain the tree die-off rate a-30 (Figure 3). Where one species featured 0-values due to 0 replication, the values of the other species were used alone. The mean value is calculated from the tree die-off rate a-30 over the 5500 years shown. 3. Results The main result of this study is that the majority of investigated trackways were found contemporaneous to tree die-off phases (section 3.2, Figure 3), which indicated water table rise and mire expansion (see sections 1. and 2.1). The die-off phases are displayed in this study by the die-off rate a-30 (3.1., Figure 2 and Figure 3). One case of contemporaneousness of trackway construction and tree die-off phase (trackway Pr 31 , 4629–4545 BC) is described more detailed (3.3., Figure 4). 3.1. Die-off phases The tree die-off rate a-30 features over-average values (regarded as die-off phases) for 40.4% of the 5500 years regarded. There are two cases of an edge-effect, where a small number of die-offs are over emphasised by the rate. This is the case around 3360 BC and around 1645 BC, where “last survivors” cover the edge of pine-chronology gaps for some decades (Figures 2 and 3). With this exception, the die-off rate a-30 refects the tree distribution very well. The two tree species show much agreement, but also differences, in their die-off curves (Figure 3). In general, the pine die-off phases are shorter and more distinct than those of the oaks (see Figures 2a and 3a, compare section 2.1.).In the study period examined, from 4750 BC to 750 AD, the distribution and appearance of die-off phases varied over time as well:The period before c. 3500 BC is well represented by both tree species. Pine and oak both show distinct and synchronous die-off phases (Figure 3a). High and distinct peaks occur approximately every 150–250 years. The die-off phases are largely related to the initiation of raised bog growth at the respective sites.Between c. 3500 BC and c. 1500 BC, the pine record produces prominent peaks, which mark raised bog expansion at inland sites, around 2880 BC, 2740 BC, 2280 BC and 2175 BC. The contemporary oaks mainly stem from low elevation sites, infuenced by groundwater. Their die-off phases appear more moderate and stretched out, as the trees die successively along an elevation gradient. An example of the discrepancy between the species is the pine-only die-off peak around 2740 BC.After c. 1500 BC, there are only a few dated pines. The oak material in this section originates from inland raised bogs, where they mark the fen-bog transition. Similar to the frst section (before c. 3500 BC), these die-off phases appear more distinct. The oak peaks around 700 BC, 550 BC and around 120 BC appear particularly clear. 3.2 Contemporaneity of trackway construction and die-off phases of the peat-preserved trees Nine of the eleven trackway construction dates (81%) clearly date within die-off phases (Figure 3). Some of them are represented by more than one trackway. However, at one of these dates (date 5), the tree die-off rate a-30 shows values only slightly above average.Two trackway construction dates are contemporaneous to below average die-off rate a-30 values. One of these, date 2 (3798 BC) dates directly (three years) after a die-off phase, and therefore appears in the context of environmental change nonetheless. By contrast, the trackway construction date 10 shows no apparent temporal relation to tree die-off phases; it dates to a period in which the tree record is represented by oak only. 3.3 Trackway Pr31 , documented for 4629–4545 BC Tree die-off is a sound hydrological indicator, but by no means the only environmental indicator contained in the dendrochronological record. In the following, tree-ring-width (TRW) variability is additionally considered for one trackway construction date. The Neolithic trackway Pr31 (date 1, 4629– after 4545 BC; Figure 4) is the oldest construction in our data. It is represented by a number of dated timbers, with a range of dates accounting for repeated work on the trackway (Figure 4a). The contemporaneous dendrochronological record is well replicated for both tree species. Pine and oak from several sites display a major die-off phase at the time (see Figures 3a and 4c). Stratigraphically, the oaks as well as the pines largely mark the beginning of raised bog growth at respective sites. Conditions stressful to the trees are also implied by the contemporaneous series of growth depressions displayed by the regional TRW-chronologies (Figure 4b, grey boxes).Samples of 36 timbers from two excavated sections of trackway Pr31 were dated. They display a range of dates, dispersed over 84 years. A number of samples preserved to bark edge, accompanied by other samples that date shortly prior to these, indicate construction and maintenance for 4629 BC, 4614 BC, 4606 BC, 4590 BC, 4557 BC and after 4545 BC (dates regarding last ring, Figure 4a).The contemporaneous die-off phase appears stretched-out long with three peaks (Figure 2a). It is refected similarly by both tree species, with some minor differences (Figure 4c).
image/svg+xmlIANSA 2015 ● VI/1 ● 19–29 Inke Achterberg, Andreas Bauerochse, Thomas Giesecke, Alf Metzler, Hanns Hubert Leuschner: Contemporaneousness of Trackway Construction and Environmental Change: a Dendrochronological Study in Northwest-German Mires 25 The supposed frst construction (4629 BC) is contemporaneous to a frst die-off pulse of the die-off phase (Figure 4c). Maintenance appears to have taken place rather continuously, as dates are scattered over the following years. The maintenance activity of 4590 BC displays the most striking concurrence: in 4590 BC, increased stress is refected by drastic declines in the oak and pine TRW-chronologies (Figure 4b). Also, the TRW- mean curve of the trackway timbers, representing a local signal, displays a sharp decline in ring width. After 4590 BC, work on the trackway seems to have come to a halt, as only two, not fully preserved, timbers date within the following 30 years. This apparent