image/svg+xml
139
V/2/2014
INTERDISCIPLINARIA ARCHAEOLOGICA
NATURAL SCIENCES IN ARCHAEOLOGY
homepage: http://www.iansa.eu
Short Contribution: Severe Enamel Defects and Malformations of Canines
in Pre-Historic and Historic Domestic Pigs from Bohemia
Wolf-Rüdiger Teegen
a
, René Kyselý
b*
a
Institut für Vor- und Frühgeschichtliche Archäologie und Provinzialrömische Archäologie & ArchaeoBioCenter, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität,
Geschwister-Scholl-Platz 1, 80539 München, Germany
b
Institute of Archaeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, v. v. i., Letenská 4, 118 00, Prague, Czech Republic
1. Introduction
Pig teeth are a grateful object for studying malformations
as well as enamel or dentine defects in veterinary anatomy
and pathology as well as in osteoarchaeology. This feld
of study has been more or less neglected, however, in
osteoarchaeology and paleopathology. Nevertheless, there
are classic observations on more recent fnds which Frank
Colyer collected in the frst decades of the 20
th
century
(Colyer 1936). Fortunately, an updated edition of his book
was published by A. E. W. Miles and Caroline Grigson in
1990. Only since the turn of the Millennium, has interested
turned toward enamel defects of pig teeth, dealing mostly,
however, with premolars and molars (
e.g.
Dobney, Ervynck
1998; 2000; 2002; Teegen, Wussow 2000; Teegen 2005;
2006; 2013; Magnell, Carter 2007; Pigière 2009).
The canines of the male pig – either of the wild (
Sus
scrofa
) or the domestic form (
Sus scrofa
f.
domestica
) –
are of particular interest. These canines are continuously
growing (elodont) and are rootless (aradicular hypsodont).
They therefore continue growing until the individual dies.
The elodont canines have an extended pulp with a rich blood
supply. There are enough cells in this and the adjacent areas
continually reproducing themselves. There is consequently
a constant stream of cells present, ready to heal damaged
tissue in the canine area (Miles, Grigson 1990, 404). This
means that the dentine cells of the canines of male pigs have
a high repair potential. This is quite different with the female
pigs (Figure 6) where the canines are not continuously
growing.
For the wild boar, tusk anomalies – mainly of the lower
canines – are sometimes described in veterinary or wildlife
literature (
e.g.
Palášthy, Palášthy 1991; Kierdorf, Rühe 2002;
Kierdorf, Kierdorf 2003; Kierdorf
et al.
2004; Konjević
et al.
2004; 2006). This is due to the fact that (mainly the lower)
tusks are valuable trophies for hunters. Alterations of the
maxillary canines are reported less (
e.g.
Konjević
et al.
2004).
Alterations of the canines of male domestic pigs have
gained much less attention then wild boars. This is the case
both for recent as well as archaeological specimens. This is
also valid for enamel hypoplasia which can often be observed
Volume V ● Issue 2/2014 ● Pages 139–146
*Corresponding author. E-mail: kysely@arup.cas.cz
ARTICLE INFO
Article history:
Received: 7. November 2014
Accepted: 23. December 2014
Keywords:
domestic pig (
Sus scrofa
f.
domestica
)
enamel defect
enamel and root hypoplasia
Iron Age (La Tène period)
Middle Ages
ABSTRACT
In this paper four cases of severe enamel and dentine defects in the upper canines of male domestic
pigs (
Sus scrofa
f.
domestica
) from the Iron Age and medieval sites in Bohemia (Czech Republic) are
presented. Such severe defects observed in the osteoarchaeological record are a fairly rare condition.
They are in all likelihood the result of intra and extra alveolar traumas. In two cases the growing area
was completely or partially divided, probably due to a traumatic incidence. The origin of the traumatic
insults could be intra- or inter-species fghts, search for food or other accidents. Human maltreatment
could also not be excluded. A twisted canine was observed in one case. A description of an anomaly on
one lower female pig canine is also included.
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2014 ● V/2 ● 139–146
Wolf-Rüdiger Teegen, René Kyselý: Short Contribution: Severe Enamel Defects and Malformations of Canines in Pre-Historic and Historic Domestic Pigs from Bohemia
140
in canines (
cf.
Teegen 2013, 60–61), as they continue to
receive less attention than molars or premolars.
The average growth rates (in mm/month) for pig canines
are also not all that well known. An average monthly growth
of approx. 2 mm can be assumed for wild boars above
20 months of age from the southern Ukraine (Woloch 2002,
188, Figure 2). It could be similar or less, probably between
1 mm and 2 mm/month, for domestic pigs.
Despite modifcations on bovine incisives having been
recently described by Kyselý (2007; 2009; 2012) and certain
other dental deformations from the Czech territory having
been mentioned occasionally, there is no paper specialised
Table 1.
Overview of the analysed fnds. Measurements in mm. Abbreviations: GE = growing end (≈EDJ = Enamel-Dentine-Junction), ED = enamel defect.
Site1: Radovesice2: Lovosice
– Resslova ulice
3a: Stará Boleslav3b: Stará Boleslav4: Prague
– Vojanovy sady
Site specifcation
Radovesice 23,
Lukovský potok,
feat. 107/72
trench 2, feat. 8,
layer 0–10 cm
trench LXX,
square 102,
layer 21225
trench XVIII,
layer 6367
layer A
Settlement
description
early La Tène
(A-B1) settlement
middle La Tène
(C) settlement
medieval stronghold
(bailey)
medieval stronghold
(moat)
medieval town
Archaeological
dating
5
th
– beginning
of the 4
th
cent. BC
3
rd
–2
nd
cent. BC
end of the 9
th
– turn
of 13
th
cent. AD
end of the 9
th
– turn
of 12
th
cent. AD
2
nd
half of the 13
th
cent. AD
Taxonomic statusdomesticdomesticdomesticdomesticdomestic
Toothleft upper canine
right upper canine
in its alveolus
left upper canineleft lower canineright upper canine
Sexmalemalemalefemalemale
Age at deathadult (> 18 months)
adult (approx.
18–24 months)
adult (older?)
(> 18 months)
adult
subadult/adult
(> 15 months)
Length41.644.2
61.838.6
Length (outer arch)52.089.041.0
Length (inner arch)41.068.035.0
Minimum diameter
at GE
8.3
12.210.910.9
Maximum diameter
at EDJ
14.4
16.3
14.318.0
Height of ED above
GE
31.7
not determinednot determined
19.0–14.1
Breadth of the defect
13.23.2 × 4.7 × 1.0
Figure23–45
6
7
Table 2.
Lovosice – Resslova ulice (nr. 2). Measurements (in mm) of the maxilla. Values in brackets = approximate.
M1-M3 P1-M3P1-P4P2-M3 P2-P4 Length of M3Breadth of M3Max. diameter of canine alveolus
(60.9)(100.8)40.2
(93.8)33.3
30.717.321.7
0 200 km
Figure 1.
Map of the Czech Republic with
the sites:1 – Radovesice, 2 – Lovosice, 3 –
Stará Boleslav, 4 – Praha (Prague). Map by
R. Kyselý.
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2014 ● V/2 ● 139–146
Wolf-Rüdiger Teegen, René Kyselý: Short Contribution: Severe Enamel Defects and Malformations of Canines in Pre-Historic and Historic Domestic Pigs from Bohemia
141
on animal tooth pathologies in Czech archaeozoological
literature. The presented report can therefore be considered
a pilot case.
2. Materials and Methods
In this short contribution we would like to present fve cases of
enamel defects on pig canines originating from archaeological
contexts in Bohemia (Czech Republic; Figure 1). Each case
originates from the La Tène sites Radovesice and Lovosice –
Resslova ulice. The other ones are Medieval and come from
Prague – Vojanovy sady and from Stará Boleslav.
All the fnds were dated by co-found artefacts (mainly
pottery) with the help of the evidence of the stratigraphic
situation (see the cited archaeological literature); radiocarbon
dating was not directly applied. It is well known that
stratigraphic contaminations can play a role in poly-cultural
archaeological situations. The evidence indicates that it is
not an issue in our cases. Despite certain older settlement
layers (11
th
to the frst half of the 13
th
century) having been
detected in the stratigraphical set at Prague – Vojanovy sady,
layer “A” only represents refuse from the second half of the
13
th
century, therefore contamination is not all that probable.
Other fnds described here are more reliable and narrowly
dated (Table 1).
Sex was determined using the morphology of the
canines. The age determination of pig canines is only
quite approximative (Habermehl 1975). For wild boars
the length of the whetting surface can be an age indicator
(Wagenknecht 1979; Habermehl 1985).
The defnitions of the measurements follow von den
Driesch (1976). The main reference point for all of the other
measurements is the Enamel-Dentine-Junction (EDJ). In
the canines of males there is only a small seam of dentine
without enamel, generally less than 5–10 mm.
The pathological changes in the maxillary canines were
classifed according to Palášthy and Palášthy (1991), Teegen
(2004), Konjević
et al.
(2004) and Konjević (2006).
3. Results
The canines belong – with one exception – to male domestic
pigs. In four out of fve cases the canines of the upper jaws
are present (Table 1). In one case (nr. 3b), the lower canine
of a female domestic pig is present. All the individuals were
at least 15 months old (Table 1).
Description of the fnds
(sorted in chronological order):
Site 1: Radovesice (distr. Litoměřice):
The canine discussed here (Table 1; Figure 2) was found
in feature 107/72 of the Iron Age village Radovesice 23,
Lukovský potok, distr. Litoměřice (Bohemia). The
excavation in 1972 was led by J. Waldhauser. The
archaeological description was published by Waldhauser
(1993), the archaeozoological report was published by Peške
(1993). The feature belongs to the settlement horizon II–III
(IIB) which is dated to La Tène A-B1 (5
th
– beginning of
4
th
century BC).
The left upper canine of an adult male domestic pig
(>18 months) is completely preserved (Figure 2). The tip
is abraded or broken. The complete tooth crown is torn at
approx. 20°. The enamel layer is only partially present.
The enamel formation at the tip of the canine is regular.
A deep sulcus with a width of about 4 mm is approximately
Figure 2.
Radovesice (Bohemia), male domestic pig, left upper canine (see Table 1 for details). 1 – Buccal view. 2 – Disto-palatinal view. 3 Distal view.
4 – Mesio-palatinal view. Large arrow heads: separated growing areas, small arrow heads: exostoses, arrow: the distal rims of the defect are clearly marked
and are forming ridges. Scale = 1 cm. Photo: W.-R. Teegen.
4321
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2014 ● V/2 ● 139–146
Wolf-Rüdiger Teegen, René Kyselý: Short Contribution: Severe Enamel Defects and Malformations of Canines in Pre-Historic and Historic Domestic Pigs from Bohemia
142
31.7 mm (linear distance) resp. 35.0 mm (curvature) above
the Enamel-Dentine-Junction (EDJ) (Figure 2). This sulcus is
present on the mesial, palatinal and distal side of the canine.
Only the buccal part shows little alterations. It is clearly visible
here, however, that the crown of this canine is torn (Figure 2.1).
If we assume a monthly growth rate of 1–2 mm, than the defect
developed between 17 and 35 months prior to death.
The disto-palatinal area of the canine reveals a quite
abnormal surface. There are holes and the enamel layer is
mostly missing. This defect has an extension of approx.
13.2 × 31.7 (linear distance) resp. 35.0 mm (curvature).
The mesial and distal rims of the defect are clearly marked
and form ridges. These defect walls contain several bubble
formed structures of a lighter colour. They in all likelihood
consist of enamel pearls. One rim measures 2.2 × 14.0 mm
with a height of approx. 2 mm. The defect itself is without
enamel. It only consists of dentine which shows three larger
holes with an irregular surface (Figure 2). The opposite
rim is more irregular; the basal is an irregular exostotic
formation of 3.9 × 6.0 × 4.0 mm dentine extension. It is
located 5 mm above the EDJ. The enamel layer runs in the
regular area to the end of the tooth to the EDJ.
Of particular interest is the fact that there are two separate
growing ends of the upper canine (Figures 2.1 and 2.2, large
arrow heads).
Site 2: Lovosice – Resslova ulice (distr. Litoměřice):
The excavation of 1986 was directed by V. Salač and
partly published in 1990 (Salač 1990). The left maxillary
fragment with the canine of a male domestic pig (inv. no.
86/2/8/341/3) was found in the middle La Tène settlement
phase in trench 2, feature 8, 0–10 cm below the top of the
feature (Table 1). It dates to the 3
rd
–2
nd
century BC. The
archaeozoological material was studied by R. Kyselý (2001)
and is still unpublished.
The pathologically altered canine was still in its alveolus
in a fragment of the left maxilla (Figure 3.1). The premolars
1–4 and molars 2 and 3 are also present. Their degree of
abrasion is low (premolars visible on Figure 3.2). It belongs
to an adult individual of approx. 20–26 months of age
1
. The
metric data can be found in Table 2.
There is a defect running perpendicular to the axis on the
distal part of the canine. It is located approx. 10 mm from
the top of the crown (Figure 4.1). Below this defect a furrow
begins which runs to the growing end. There is also an ara of
about 10.2 ×19.9 mm distally which shows irregular dentine
and enamel formation. Below the defect on the distal side
there are also irregularities in the enamel formation on the
palatinal part of the canine (Figure 4.2).
The growing end is partially compressed and exhibits
distally a deep longitudinal furrow which nearly separates it
(Figure 4.1). There is some new dentine formation inside the
growing end, attached to the furrow (Figure 4.1).
1
Molar 2 has dentine abraded (
cf.
Grant’s 1982 stage “e–f”); molar 3 only
has enamel abraded (Grant’s 1982 stage “a”).