image/svg+xml
37
XII/1/2021
INTERDISCIPLINARIA ARCHAEOLOGICA
NATURAL SCIENCES IN ARCHAEOLOGY
homepage: http://www.iansa.eu
On the Tracks of Aswan Pink Clay. New Studies on the Local Clay Deposits
in the Region of Aswan/Upper Egypt
Laura Rembart
1
, Lisa Betina
2*
1
Austrian Archaeological Institute, Franz Klein-Gasse 1, 1190 Vienna, Austria
2
Saxo Institute, University of Copenhagen, Karen Blixens Plads 8, 2300 Copenhagen, Denmark
1. Introduction
One of the most important ceramic production centres of
the post-Pharaonic period in ancient Egypt is situated in
the Aswan region in Upper Egypt and it was specialised
in the manufacture of ceramic artefacts made of so-called
“Pink Clay”. Modern Aswan is synonymous with the
ancient cities of Syene and Elephantine, which evolved into
a political and economic centre around the frst Nile cataract
already in the Ptolemaic period. Geographically, Syene
represents the southernmost town in the Ptolemaic empire
and subsequently in the Roman Empire. This prominent
position, along with the nearby island of Elephantine, was
of particular signifcance with respect to, for example, the
exchange of goods with Nubia to the south, and trade with the
well-known rose granite extracted from local quarries since
Pharaonic times. The granite was distributed northwards
through the river ports of both Syene and Elephantine.
Syene thus fourished, particularly due to the trade, and
reached an economic upturn in Hellenistic times, which is
recognizable by the expansion of the inhabited city area.
Elephantine was famous in Pharaonic times primarily
because of its religious cult sites around the annual Nile food.
In the 5
th
century CE, the temple areas were successively
released for secular development and the island remained –
despite the conquest of Upper Egypt by the Arabs in 642 CE
– continuously inhabited until the early Islamic period.
In 2011, the Austrian Science Fund-Project “Housing in
Antiquity in Syene/Elephantine, Upper Egypt” directed by
S. Ladstätter at the Austrian Archaeological Institute (OeAI)
in cooperation with the Swiss Institute for Archaeological
and Architectural Research on Ancient Egypt in Cairo (SIK)
was begun. The main goal of this three-year project was
a socio-cultural interpretation of Syene and Elephantine
from the Late Ptolemaic period until late antiquity, based
on the material legacy from diferent residential buildings.
The pottery fnds from Syene originate from excavations in
Area 2 and Area 13c. In both areas residential buildings were
uncovered which were used continuously from the Ptolemaic
period to at least the middle Roman Imperial period;
residential buildings with adjoining courtyards for household
activities along narrow alleys have been uncovered, which
have been rebuilt several times in the course of time. The
pottery from Elephantine comes from residential complexes,
Volume XII ● Issue 1/2021 ● Pages 37–44
*Corresponding author. E-mail: lisa.peloschek@gmail.com
ARTICLE INFO
Article history:
Received: 9
th
September 2020
Accepted: 28
th
January 2021
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2021.1.3
Key words:
Egypt
pottery production
kaolinitic clay
geological feldwork
ABSTRACT
Using Ptolemaic to late antiquity pottery assemblages from Aswan (ancient Syene) as a case study, we
demonstrate the imperative nature of petrographic analyses combined with geological feld surveys
when investigating ancient potting centres. The combination of archaeological (
i.e.
abundance of
ceramics, vessel shapes
etc.
), macroscopic and natural-scientifc methods allows the reconstruction
of the possible extraction areas of clays utilised in Aswan, Upper Egypt. Knowledge of specifc clays
and their compositional characteristics helps to establish archaeometric reference groups, necessary
for diferentiating kaolinitic clay sediments of the Aswan area from similar geological environments
further down the Nile valley.
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2021 ● XII/1 ● 37–44
Laura Rembart, Lisa Betina: On the Tracks of Aswan Pink Clay. New Studies on the Local Clay Deposits in the Region of Aswan/Upper Egypt
38
so-called tower houses, which were built in the area of the
former temple of Chnum in the 5
th
century CE and were in
use until the end of the 7
th
century (Figure 1).
Petrographic analysis of the pottery was an essential
component of the project in order to diferentiate imported
vessels from those produced in the local potteries of
Aswan and its surroundings. Focus was hereby on ceramics
macroscopically assigned to “Pink Clay”, for which only
a handful of references are available up to now. Petrographic
signatures of the clay have been generated and a certain
diversity in the mineral and rock inclusions noted, allowing
the identifcation of four Aswan Pink Clay-variants.
In the following we report on a geological survey that
has been conducted with the aim to identify potential source
areas of these characteristic clays. Besides the collection of
clay samples, the collection and subsequent analysis of rock
samples was of particular signifcance, as in thin-section the
mineral constituents and quantities of individual minerals
in the rocks can be identifed. Can traces of such rock
fragments be found in the clays sampled in the region? Can
traces of such rock fragments and their mineral compounds
be detected in ancient pottery fragments? Most importantly,
can the origin of Aswan Pink Clay from kaolinite weathered
from granite be confrmed?
2. State of research, methodology and theoretical approach
In 2009, the recording of the pottery fnds was initiated; some
of the excavated layers consisted exclusively of ceramics,
which meant that huge amounts of material were gathered.
The pottery recording was carried out in several campaigns
in Aswan and was limited on site to the fnd statistics,
in which all fragments were counted and statistically
registered. Furthermore, the ceramics have been graphically
and photographically documented, and diagnostic pieces
described in a
Microsoft Access
database containing all the
relevant information, such as measurements, ceramic fabrics
and decoration.
A total of nearly 200,000 pottery fragments were recorded
statistically. Of these 5% were included in the database as
diagnostic fragments – considered as such were rim and
base fragments, as well as wall fragments with decoration,
and also body sherds of imported pottery. These diagnostic
fragments were assigned to the respective ware groups. In
this regard, the material from Syene can be diferentiated
into tableware, coarseware, kitchenware, transport amphorae
and lamps (Rembart, 2020).
For decades, the “Vienna System” has been used for
the classifcation of Egyptian ceramics on a macroscopic
level (basic reading: Arnold and Bourriau, 1993; Bourriau
et al.
, 2000; Nordström and Bourriau, 1993). However,
this system was developed for the description of Pharaonic
ceramics from a limited number of archaeological sites and
is therefore difcult to use for the Ptolemaic, Roman and late
antiquity ceramic fabrics of Upper Egypt. For this reason,
we deliberately refrained from using the Vienna System
when processing the pottery from Syene and Elephantine
and instead developed a guidance system based on new
criteria, primarily considering the clays’ mineral and rock
Figure 1.
Map of Elephantine and modern Aswan (the excavation areas are marked in red).
0 2 km
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2021 ● XII/1 ● 37–44
Laura Rembart, Lisa Betina: On the Tracks of Aswan Pink Clay. New Studies on the Local Clay Deposits in the Region of Aswan/Upper Egypt
39
inclusions. The main focus of the analyses was on the local
kaolinitic clay pastes subsumed under the term Aswan Pink
Clay (Peloschek and Katzjäger, 2017; Katzjäger, Peloschek
and Rembart, 2016).
Due to the exploitation of the native clay deposits,
the region of Syene developed into a signifcant ceramic
production centre at the beginning of the 2
nd
century BCE
(Rembart, 2020). According to the completed statistical
analysis, 10% of the vessels were made of the local clay paste
in Hellenistic and Roman times, while 75% of the overall
late antiquity ceramic material is represented by Aswan Pink
Clay (Figure 2). This clay paste was used for the production
of diferent kinds of wares and vessel forms, with tableware
and amphorae dominating by far (Figure 3).
Based on the results of the statistical analysis of the
archaeological ceramics, various research questions were
developed. The most obvious one was the quantitative
increase of ceramics fabricated from Aswan Pink Clay during
the centuries, which made us wonder about the temporal
dependency of the clay selection criteria. Can it be supposed
that the dramatic rise in the exploitation of Aswan Pink Clay
over the centuries relates more to the expanding knowledge
of mining sites of appropriate raw clays in the broader
environs of Aswan? In order to review these assumptions,
the composition and characteristics of the clays utilised
in the pottery production and the raw materials accessible
needed to be compared.
To consider macroscopic characteristics and vessel
typology, 29 ceramic samples were taken for petrographic
analysis. Geological clay and sediment samples were soaked
in water, homogenised and levigated, before being fred
at 850 °C in an electrical furnace and consequently thin-
sectioned. This allowed for a straightforward comparative
analysis of both ceramic and clay samples.
3. Results and discussion
“Pink Clay” (Rodziewicz, 1992) is the term used in literature
for an Egyptian clay tentatively connected to kaolinitic
Figure 2.
Distribution of the fabrics.
Figure 3.
Collection of Roman and late antiquity tableware.
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2021 ● XII/1 ● 37–44
Laura Rembart, Lisa Betina: On the Tracks of Aswan Pink Clay. New Studies on the Local Clay Deposits in the Region of Aswan/Upper Egypt
40
sediments. The Aswan Pink Clay sediments are supposed to
derive from the decomposition of pinkish feldspar minerals
found in the local rose granite, available abundantly in the
entire broader area (Soliman, 1985).
3.1 Petrographic analysis
Petrographic analyses allowed a diferentiation of four
clay pastes based on the character of non-plastic inclusions
embedded in the clay matrices. The petrofabric ASW-PC_01
can be designated as the typical, most common Aswan Pink
Clay already described by Tomber and Williams (1996)
who were the frst to examine a sherd of Aswan Pink Clay
pottery in thin-section. Figure 4 highlights the most diagnostic
characteristics of ASW-PC_01, defned amongst others
by quartz, shale, kaolinitic clay pellets, feldspars, chert or
volcanic rock inclusions in the coarse fraction. Rock fragments
of granite, pellets of Nile mud or amphiboles can also occur in
lower quantities. Petrofabric ASW-PC_04, is a relatively pure
and fne-grained kaolinitic sediment containing only traces of
shale, chert and volcanic rock fragments in a kaolinitic clay
groundmass. Two other variants of Aswan Pink Clay deviate
slightly: Petrofabric ASW-PC_02 has an increased content of
Figure 4.
Characteristic inclusions of Aswan Pink Clay in thin-section (xpl): 1. Kaolinitic clay pellet; 2. Quartz, K-feldspars and amphibole; 3. Granite;
4. Pellet of Nile mud; 5. Shale; 6. and 7. Volcanic rock fragments; 8. Amphibole.