image/svg+xml
85
XII/1/2021
InterdIscIplInarIa archaeologIca
natural scIences In archaeology
homepage: http://www.iansa.eu
Book reviews
Volume XII ● Issue 1/2021 ● Pages 85–87
Reconstructing Archaeological Sites:
Understanding the Geoarchaeological
Matrix
Panagiotis Karkanas, Paul Goldberg
Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford (2019), 296 pp.,
ISBN 9781119016403.
They also make an attempt to throw light
on the various phases of soil formation
and post-depositional processes found
at archaeological sites, and particularly
concerning the methodology of its study.
The attempt to include and understand
postdepositional processes in their fnal
interpretation is quite rare in textbooks
presently available: readers usually have
to combine geoarchaeology with soil
science. On the other hand, Karkanas and
Goldberg (2019) is not the frst book
pointing out the importance of the
connection between primary formation
processes and soil-forming processes
macroscopically (Holliday, 1992), or
by a micromorphological approach (Stoops
et al.
, 2010), or by both (Macphail and
Goldberg, 2017).
In contrast to the above-mentioned books
on geoarchaeology where the description
of basic natural formation processes is the
key part of the introduction, Karkanas and
Goldberg focus on the most widespread
type of formation process – mass
movement. They frst published this
concept when introducing a diferent
type of colluvial deposits by way of
micromorphology (Karkanas and Goldberg,
2008). This has also been successfully
applied in studies from the Czech Republic
concerning the type of slope deposits inside
a rondel structure (Lisá
et al.
, 2015), or
the formation processes of cave inflls
(Nejman
et al.
, 2018; Lisá
et al.
, 2013).
The reader might fnd it a little confusing
that some of the basic formation process
descriptions are relatively short (
e.g.
fuvial
or aeolian processes) or even missing
(glacial processes), but on the other hand,
when we take into consideration the fact that
most archaeological situations are covered
by various types of colluvial deposits, than
such a distinction makes sense.
The basic colluvial deposit descriptions
mentioned in this book are followed
by their recognition in the feld, by
micromorphological observations, and also
their efect on the archaeological material
under discussion. They are divided into:
(1) slides and slumps; (2) rock debris
falls and avalanches and grain fows;
(3) solifuction; (4) debris fows and
mudfows; (5) hyperconcentrated fows;
(6) high-energy fows; and, they more
or less connect the fuvial process with
the colluvial one in the sense of (7) water
fows in sites, and (8) shallow water fows.
The set of presented processes is completed
by aeolian processes and by a set of
biological processes. The description
of post-sedimentary processes, including
bioturbation, erosion, diagenesis, or
soil-forming processes, is presented in the
same way,
i.e.
frstly a description of their
appearance, followed by their recognition
in the feld, micromorphology, and their
efect on the archaeological material. Thus,
this book is theoretically grounded and
methodologically clear – and yet remains
innovative. Such a guide book provides
a perfect framework for the interpretation
of both natural and anthropogenic
sediments, and the reconstruction of the
history of a site’s deposits along with
the formation of a site. It also tries to be
a practical guide: through its various
“boxes” of information, diagrams, and
photos that provide guidelines for both
feld and laboratory methodology. In our
view, an understanding of all the described
processes is necessary for a clarifcation of
the development of anthropogenic sites and
site stratigraphy (
cf.
Butzer, 1982; Renfrew,
1976; Shackley, 1976).
In this short review, we would like
to refrain from commenting on specifc
chapters, which difer in their quality and
depth. Chapter 1 presents guidelines for
site formation processes. It introduces the
many types of diverse processes that can
afect an archaeological site before, during,
and after its occupation. These may be, for
example, soil formation, developmental
processes, and post-depositional events.
This frst chapter gives us a context for
understanding the history of a site and
helps us answer the question of a site’s
formation by way of its three-dimensional
stratigraphy (
cf.
Weiner, 2010). By defning
the stratigraphy, we can then envision some
aspects of the dynamic three-dimensional
The book “Reconstructing Archaeological
Sites” by P. Karkanas and Paul Goldberg
is an attempt to show to the reader
another way of how to understand
and interpret archaeological deposits.
Most of the geoarchaeology books
introduce geoarchaeology as an attempt to
understand the various formation processes
of natural sediments, which are in some way
linked to the archaeological context (French,
2012; Rapp and Hill, 2006; Goldberg
and Macphail, 2006; Macphail and
Goldberg, 2017). In stark contrast to this,
Karkanas and Goldberg introduce all
sediments linked to the archaeological
context as archaeological sediments. These
sediments are generally divided into:
(a) those deposited by natural processes, but
without materials produced, modifed, or re-
organized by humans; (b) those deposited
by natural processes, but also containing
anthropogenic materials; and (c) materials
(natural or anthropogenic) deposited only
by anthropogenic activities and processes.