image/svg+xml
103
XI/1/2020
INTERDISCIPLINARIA ARCHAEOLOGICA
NATURAL SCIENCES IN ARCHAEOLOGY
homepage: http://www.iansa.eu
Soil Chemistry to Support Old Map Analysis of the Built-up Area of an
Abandoned Settlement. Case Study from the Romanian Banat
Markéta Šantrůčková
a*
, Jan Horák
b
, Václav Fanta
b
a
Silva Tarouca Research Institute for Landscape and Ornamental Gardening, Květnové náměstí 391, 252 43 Průhonice, Czech Republic
b
Faculty of Environmental Sciences, Czech University of Life Sciences, Kamýcká 129, 165 21 Prague 6 – Suchdol, Czech Republic
1. Introduction
The landscape is still changing, and many authors (Antrop,
2005; Dossche
et al.
, 2016; Wulf
et al.
, 2016) have stressed
that landscape changes in Europe have accelerated from
the end of the 18
th
century. Landscape studies focused on
land use and land cover changes have a tradition in all parts
of Europe (Jepsen
et al.
, 2015; Kuemmerle
et al.
, 2016),
as well as in selected regions and land categories (Forejt
et al.
, 2017; Skaloš
et al.
, 2011; Šantrůčková
et al.
, 2015;
Wulf
et al.
, 2016). The Romanian mountains seem to be a
stable area in macroscopic analyses on a European scale
(Jepsen
et al.
, 2015; Kuemmerle
et al.
, 2016), but important
settlement and land use/land cover changes have occurred
there since the nineteenth century (Cepraga, 2014; Romportl
et al.
, 2014; Šantrůčková, Fanta, 2014; Kovář
et al.
, 2019).
These changes were connected with the resettlement of
Romanian mountains at the beginning of the nineteenth
century, which caused an intensifcation of agriculture and
mining activities (Šantrůčková, Klvač, 2014). On the other
hand, the Romanian mountains are still one of the hotspots
of the traditional cultural landscape in Europe due to their
isolation, geographical conditions and ethnographical
diversity (Solymosi, 2011). The study of the frst settlement
activities and landscape changes at the beginning of the
nineteenth century requires the combining of diferent
sources and methods. Our paper proposes the combination
of geochemical methods used by environmental archaeology
with the study of cartographical sources and old grey
literature.
The relationship between human settlement activities and
the soil part of the biosphere has been intensively studied
over the decades, which has introduced a wide spectrum
of topics: the infuence of the soils on the placement of
human activities in the landscape; the interaction between
human activities and the soils; the role of soils as one of the
basic archives of archaeological evidence; and the role of
human activities as a pedogenic factor (Bork
et al.
, 1998;
Walkington, 2010; Fanta
et al.
, 2018). Nevertheless, there
are also incentives for a more comprehensive research, as
many projects are still focused on either an historical or a
Volume XI ● Issue 1/2020 ● Pages 103–115
*Corresponding author. E-mail: santruckova@vukoz.cz
ARTICLE INFO
Article history:
Received: 23
rd
May 2019
Accepted: 8
th
June 2020
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2020.1.8
Key words:
multi-element analysis
XRF
GIS interpolation
settlement development
old maps
abandoned village
ABSTRACT
This paper focuses on the combination of geochemical methods and old map analysis to study
landscape and settlement development. It is well known that historical land use of abandoned rural
settlements afects soil chemistry and vegetation composition. We wanted to fnd out whether it is
possible to distinguish various historical land uses when we know the current chemical composition
of the soil; in particular, whether it is possible to recognize the presence of an abandoned village.
Geochemical measurement was combined with old maps and grey literature analysis. The model area
in the Romanian Banat Mountains is well documented by preserved old maps and is even documented
by a land allocation plan from the beginning of the 19
th
century colonization. This unique document
was compared with other old maps, and the spatial development of the rural settlement in the Romanian
Banat was analysed. The geochemical methods revealed interpretable patterns, but in situations of
little-known historical context (we do not know which households were really inhabited); the use of
other supporting methods (archaeological topography, geophysics) is recommended.
image/svg+xml
IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 103–115
Markéta Šantrůčková, Jan Horák, Václav Fanta: Soil Chemistry to Support Old Map Analysis of the Built-up Area of an Abandoned Settlement.
Case Study from the Romanian Banat
104
natural perspective, without the two perspectives being
brought together. For example, Rainer Schreg (2014) writes
about the need to use an ecological approach in landscape
archaeology, where the traditional approaches typically
aim only at the reconstruction of the environment. We see
the topic from another side: a lack of archaeological and
paleoenvironmental methods being combined with purely
historical topics – and with medieval and modern periods
(at least in the central European area, where environmental
archaeology chiefy researches prehistoric times).
Soils at archaeological sites are studied in many ways:
macroscopically (Kristiansen, 2001); micromorphologically;
and geochemically. Some studies have focused on using
phosphorus (Holliday, Gartner, 2007), and other studies
have focused on using multi-element analyses. These
analyses have mostly focused only on the diferentiation of
basic archaeological features (houses, felds, hearths,
etc.
),
on the verifcation of human activities, and on analysing the
spatial distribution of these activities (Davidson
et al.
, 2007;
Nielsen, Kristiansen, 2014; Roos, Nolan, 2012). The topic
of the spatial extent of particular activities (
e.g.
manuring)
or land-use types (arable feld, pastures, meadows, gardens)
has also been studied (Entwistle
et al.
, 1998; Entwistle
et al.
,
2000; Salisbury, 2013). A study coming from Romania
(Pîrnău
et al.
, 2020) has also been published.
It is well known that historical land use of abandoned
rural settlements afects soil chemistry and vegetation
composition, even over the long term (Hejcman
et al.
, 2013;
Hejcman
et al.
, 2013; Součková
et al.
, 2013). Therefore,
our question was whether it is possible to distinguish
various historical land uses if we know the current
chemical composition of the soil; in particular, whether it is
possible to recognize the presence of an abandoned village.
The present study focused on the settlement development
of Eibenthal village in the Romanian Banat, which was
colonized in the 1820s by Czech inhabitants. This village
was selected to be a model area because the village history
is well documented by preserved old maps (even by a land
allocation plan from the beginning of this colonization).
Moreover, the story of recolonization, place translations
and shifts are typical for many settlements in such history
(Hill, 2013; Klápště, 2012).
Our aims were the following: 1) to determine if the
Eibenthal settlement was realized to the full extent as
recorded on old maps and 2) to determine how this question
can be answered using spatial analysis of geochemical
patterns. To sum up, we want to examine whether simple
geochemical analysis can be helpful for the historical
geographical research on abandoned settlements and what
are the limitations of this approach.
Figure 1.
Location of the study area and Eibenthal village. Map sources: ESRI, Word (2017), Romanian topographic map 1:25 000 (probably 1970s).